Why Your Doctor’s Advice to Avoid the Sun Has been Harming You All These Years

Why Your Doctor’s Advice to Avoid the Sun Has been Harming You All These Years

Public health officials have been recommending long sleeves, hats, and copious sunscreen for years. They say avoiding the sun’s harmful rays is the best way to protect your health and prevent cancer. But a new study reveals that such advice may be doing more harm than good. As it turns out, most people in the United States don’t get enough sun.

The study, published in the journal Dermo-Endocrinology, reveals your doctor’s advice is probably misguided and based on a few misconceptions.

“Unfortunately they have been focusing on the big C — cancer of the skin — not realizing that avoidance of sunlight has many more significant health consequences,” one of the study’s authors and professor of medicine, physiology and biophysics at Boston University, Dr. Michael Holick, told Lady Freethinker. “Most important is that they relate sun exposure to the deadly melanoma when they don’t realize most melanomas occur on the least sun-exposed areas and occupational sun exposure decreases risk.”

Along with Dr. Holick, three other doctors contributed to the study: Dr. Marianne Berwick, a professor of dermatology and internal medicine at the University of Mexico; Dr. Frank de Gruijl, an associate professor of dermatology at Leiden University in the Netherlands; and Dr. David Hoel, who served on the World Health Organization’s International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) panel of experts.

Drawing on research from over 100 other studies, the authors conclude that daily, moderate non-burning sun exposure is beneficial to humans.

Girl dancing in the sun.

Picture by Julia Caesar via Unsplash.

There are several reasons you might want to get outside to soak up the sun, according to the study:

  1. People who spend their days working outside actually have lower incidences of melanoma than people who work inside. This goes against the idea that limiting sun exposure can reduce the risk of melanoma and other types of skin cancers.
  2. In the U.S., as many as 300,000 deaths a year can be attributed to low levels of vitamin D, and most Americans don’t get enough of this nutrient. Vitamin D is a hormone, and very important for most bodily functions.
  3. Supplements aren’t a good solution, either. The skin is very efficient at producing vitamin D, so even spending a few minutes a day in the sun (as long as it doesn’t burn) can produce the same amount of vitamin D it would take to take or eat ridiculously high doses of the nutrient.
  4. The sun has other benefits, not just vitamin D production. Being in the sun also produces nitric oxide, which may help reduce hypertension and prevent obesity and metabolic syndrome.
  5. Avoiding the sun has a number of negative health consequences, including an increased risk of many types of cancer, cardiovascular disease, Alzheimer’s disease and dementia, diabetes, multiple sclerosis, myopia and macular degeneration.

However, you might not want to throw out your summer hat just yet. Just because some sun is good for you doesn’t mean you should tan for hours at the beach, either.

Little girl carrying little boy outside in the sun.

Picture by Jenn Richardson via Unsplash.

How to determine the amount of sun you need each day

Although there isn’t an exact consensus, researchers and health officials generally agree that vitamin D blood levels between 40–60 ng/mL are in the normal range. But without taking a blood test, how can you make sure you get enough sun (and vitamin D)?

The amount of sun each person needs depends on a lot of factors, such as skin pigmentation, latitude, time of day and time of year. The most important thing is being able to get enough sun for your body and location in a safe way – aka, without the burn.

“To overcome all these challenges we developed an app, dminder.info, that’s free and will tell you anywhere on the globe when you can make vitamin D, how much you will make and when to get out of the sun so that you don’t get a sunburn,” said Dr. Holick.

Older woman applying sunscreen to child's face.

By National Cancer Institute, via Wikimedia Commons

Sunscreen isn’t as great as you’ve been led to believe

As for sunscreen, its so-called benefits haven’t really been proven, and it may even be contributing to the problem.

According to Dr. Holick, using an SPF 30 sunscreen correctly can reduce vitamin D production by 98 percent. If you cover yourself when you go outside or always wear sunscreen, you may be missing out on major benefits.

What’s more, sunscreen may not even protect against melanoma.

The study’s authors warn that melanoma has increased in recent years. In 1935, the rate of melanoma was 1 in 100,000. By 2012, it jumped to 23 in 100,000. Although the exact reasons for the leap are unclear, the study authors have a theory.

“The public health messages of the past 50 [years] to avoid sun exposure and to use chemical sunscreens may have contributed to the rise in melanoma incidence,” the authors warn.

If you avoid the sun or always use sunscreen, your skin never gets used to the sun and it becomes easier to burn when you do go outside without protection. Other studies confirm this. A 2011 study showed people who used sunscreen regularly were actually more likely to get burned. Combined with low levels of vitamin D, avoiding the sun may even have contributed to increased rates of melanoma.

“Since public health authorities recommend liberal use of sunscreens for good health, the labeling of sunscreens should contain a statement about the possibility of vitamin D deficiency that may result from excessive use of sunscreens,” the study’s authors advise. “Labeling should also state that sunscreens have not been shown to be effective in reducing the risk of melanoma.”

Woman sitting in the grass taking in the sun.

Picture by SplitShire via Pexels.

The takeaway

Sun, and spending a moderate amount of time in it no matter what your age, is good for your health and wellbeing — as long as you don’t burn.

“The message of sun avoidance must be changed,” the study authors write.

It’s time for public health advisors and doctors to stop warning against the sun. Most people spend too much time indoors.

Getting officials to change their recommendations, however, might not be so easy. They’ve been doling out the same, easy message for a few decades — just avoid the sun. Now, that message has to change to advise people to spend a moderate amount of time in the sun each day. Since the amount of time each person needs varies, and each person’s skin is unique, doctors won’t have an easy, one-size-fits-all message.

“It will take a lot of reeducation,” said Holick.

In the meantime, don’t be afraid to step outside for a little while every day to soak in the sun.

Note: Please keep comments peaceful and family friendly.

Join the Conversation


  1. Marc

    Lori, what a terrific article! This new research has gotten a terrific number of online traffic and is teaching people what they have always always inherently known: sunlight is good for us. I was happy that the research brought out the fact that sunscreens are a multi-million-dollar fraud that have not reduced melanoma as more and more people use them. Something else that need to by mentioned it the production of nitric oxide by sunlight, as well as the production of serotonin and endorphin. All of these substances are vital to human health. Too may people believe that vitamin D is the only photoproduct of sun exposure. Nothing could be further from the truth. Here are a few facts about sun exposure, some of which may be new to you:
    •As sun exposure in the U.S. has DECREASED by 90% during the last century, melanoma incidence has INCREASED BY 3,000%.
    •A 20-year Swedish study shows that sun avoidance is as bad for the health as cigarette smoking.
    •A Spanish study shows that women who seek the sun have one-eleventh the hip fracture risk as those who avoid sun.
    •Men who work outdoors have half the risk of melanoma as those who work indoors.
    •Women who totally avoid the sun have 10-times the risk of breast cancer as those who embrace the sun.
    •Women who sunbathe regularly have half the risk of death during a 20-year period compared to those who stay indoors.
    •Sun exposure increases nitric oxide production, which leads to a decrease in heart attack risk.
    •Vitamin D, the sunshine vitamin, is essential to human survival, and sun exposure is the only natural way to obtain it. Sunbathing can produce 20,000 units of vitamin D in 20 minutes of whole-body exposure.
    •Sun exposure dramatically improves mood through the production of serotonin and endorphin.
    •Beyond vitamin D, sun exposure also stimulates the production of endorphin, nitric oxide and BDNF, all of which are vital to human health.
    •Regular sun exposure also reduces high blood pressure, heart disease, psoriasis and multiple sclerosis (MS).
    •As sunscreen use has increased dramatically, melanoma has INCREASED exponentially.

    For the scientific references and articles for the above statements, visit http://sunlightinstitute.org/

    Reply Report comment
    • Lori Bell

      Thanks for contributing some more information Marc – some of that information was included in the recent study, too like the fact nitric oxide can help decrease the risk of heart attack. It seems like the evidence is pretty overwhelming! I don’t know why we’ve been avoiding the sun for so long! I think this just goes along with the need to spend more outside and being active in general. Being outside isn’t just good because we get sunshine, either. People who spend time in nature feel calmer and exercise, even brisk walking has endless benefits. As a society we’ve been spending so much time inside, but hopefully we can get back out there again!

      Reply Report comment

Get The Newsletter!

Fields marked with an * are required